There’s a movie coming out next weekend that has me thinking about how terribly, god-awful, STUPID movies get made. The movie in question now has ads running on television and no, it’s not “Transformers: Age Of Extinction.”
You see, there’s a subtle but important distinction here. “Transformers” is without a doubt a bad movie, but it’s not always (only occasionally) a stupid movie. It has little to no plot, what plot it does have has more holes than a ton of Swiss cheese, the acting is lame, it’s about twice as long as it needs to be, it’s about twice as loud as it needs to be, and in general it’s just two and a half hours of Michael Bey venting adolescent hormones all over the screen in the form of crashes, chases, explosions, fights, and the best special effects $210 million can buy.
That’s bad. But is it stupid? Well, the first three “Transformers” movies cost $545 million to make and have worldwide gross revenues of $2.670 billion dollars, something like a 500% return on investment. It would be hard to argue that the people making the films are stupid, although I might question the folks handing over $12 to $20 a pop to see it.
I’m not talking about a different kind of bad movie, the movie that’s simply poorly written, or acted, or filmed, or edited. I think of recent films such as “A Dangerous Method.” Ninety-nine minutes of my life that I’ll never get back and I spent every single one of them wondering why I was watching to begin with and why I was still watching. Thank god I at least didn’t pay to watch it.
I’m not talking about movies that are “stupid” on purpose, but are in fact brilliant. “Blazing Saddles,” “Animal House,” “Monty Python & The Holy Grail,” all would qualify as “stupid” to many age groups and demographics, yet they’re truly inspired lunacy and side-splitting funny. In that respect, they’re supposed to be “stupid,” that’s how they get their point across.
No, my main definition of a STUPID movie is one where the basic, core tenet of the plot, the linchpin, is so ludicrous that you can’t even conceive of anyone ever in a million years getting the go-ahead to spend tens or hundreds of millions of dollars to make the film. How did a movie this flawed, illogical, and insane ever get through the entire process without someone pointing out “the Emperor had no clothes,” i.e., no one over the age of about six months would look at the plot without screwing up their face and wondering “WTF!!”
For decades, my hands-down winner for this category was a 1981 film starring Kurt Russell, Lee Van Cleef, Ernest Borgnine, Donald Pleasance, Isaac Hayes, Harry Dean Stanton, and Adrienne Barbeau. I speak of course, of “Escape From New York.”
Let’s run down some of the key plot points:
- Manhattan has been turned into a maximum security prison with all of the criminals in the country thrown in and left to rot. (Wait, where do we build prisons? Out in the middle of the deserts and boonies. Why? Because the land there is dirt cheap. Manhattan is dirt cheap? Nope, Manhattan is one of the two or three most expensive pieces of real estate on the freakin’ planet. Yeah, let’s build a prison there.)
- When Manhattan was evacuated, all of the furniture, cars, business files, books, and so on was left behind for the prisoners to loot. (Wait, the government comes in and grabs the most expensive piece of real estate on the freakin’ planet, kicks out every millionaire, billionaire, trillionaire, and Fortune 5000 company on the planet, and not only do they go, but they leave all of their stuff behind, as do all of the ordinary citizens who live there. Yeah, that makes sense!)
- The President of the United States just had a top secret conference with the Premier of the Soviet Union and they single-handedly worked together to forge a plan for world peace. (Wait, you mean this might be the plot point in this list that makes the most sense?)
- Their top secret agreement is recorded on a tape cassette. A single cassette. No copies. No notes. No way to recreate it if that one audio tape cassette is lost or destroyed. (Wait, I’ll be the first to go off on how stupid and incompetent government bureaucrats and politicians are, but this is so incredibly far beyond that level of stupid that you couldn’t reach it in our lifetimes with Warp Drive.)
- The President, carrying that one single copy of the magical agreement on that magical audio cassette, has crashed onboard Air Force One into Manhattan, which as we recall, is now the single, immense prison holding every criminal in America. (Wait — okay having the President in a huge freakin’ prison makes sense on so many other levels, but for the sake of this movie, what are the odds that with the entire freakin’ planet to crash onto, he went down in that particular spot?)
Do we have the setup for the plot clear now? As I remember (it’s been decades since I’ve been forced to watch) all of these plot points are established in the first ten or fifteen minutes, before the real action starts. From here on the movie makes even less sense.
I don’t despise “Escape From New York” because it’s got bad acting, moronic subplots, and stereotyped cinematic memes. (The big countdown to certain death! The tough gun moll who’s actually got a heart of gold! The bad guy antihero who really is saving the world because the world needs saving (damn it!) and not because he’s been promised a pardon.) I despise “Escape From New York” because from the very first frame it sounds like it was written, produced, and directed by a bunch of insane monkeys on LSD!
With this cinematic gem as the gold standard for “STUPID!!!”, what new movie could come along that could rival it, perhaps even surpass it?
Have you heard of “The Purge” and the sequel that opens next week, “The Purge: Anarchy”?
Here’s how it starts — in 2022, the US government thinks that it can lower the skyrocketing crime rate by having a twelve-hour holiday once a year when nothing is illegal, and actions such as murder, rape, assault, looting, and terrorism are not only allowed, but they’re encouraged. It sort of “gets it all out of our system” in one fell swoop, which in turn lets us be angels for the other 364 1/2 days of the year.
(Wait…)
Ladies and gentlemen, now we have a horse race on our hands! Which of these two wretched stinkers can prove to be so STUPID that brain cells start dying every time you see one of their billboards or television ads? Which waste of resources can prove to be so senseless that there are Pet Rocks saying, “Shit, I can do better than that!”
Answering those questions is left as an exercise for someone else, someone I pity. My vision of hell involves seeing these movies in an endless loop for all of eternity.
Finally, for the record, the first “Purge” movie last year cost $3 million to make and took in a worldwide gross of just under $90 million, a 3000% return on investment.
I weep for our society.